The hoop returns.
Let me start with a confession. Apart from this little piece here, I cannot claim to have finished any embroidery projects before, apart from embroidering eyes and such like onto faces of toys. I remember a basic cross stitch piece I did on our honeymoon nearly 20 years ago, and tinkered with some basic stitches a bit just for fun, but alas no finished projects under my belt. For a while now however, I was keen to try my hands at embroidery, but had no idea where to start. A counted thread technique sounded like a good place to start, that at least eliminates the question of where to place the stitches, right? But when does anyone have the time to just sit and stitch?
Just before we went on holiday, I had this crazy idea of taking a small, manageable-sized embroidery project with me to keep me busy on the long flight and perhaps in the evenings, if I still had the energy to concentrate on something. I looked at cross stitch patterns but nothing caught my attention in particular… until… until I saw something that looked a bit like cross stitch, but was more airy, more elegant, more geometric and immediately I knew I wanted to do something like that. You know, I love symmetry. The scientist comes out and interferes with real life occasionally.
The thing I found, and so much liked, was a piece of blackwork, a heart sampler that I found deep in the guts of Pinterest. I had no idea where to start, or how to do it. I googled and read some tutorials. It turned out that blackwork is worked on evenweave fabric, can be done on a piece of Aida cloth, for instance. This was good news, as my local Hobbycraft stocks 14 count Aida. It can also be worked with standard cotton stranded embroidery floss. Again, quite abundant, Hobbycraft holds DMC and Anchor embroidery flosses. The stitches are so easy, that they are almost trivial: one just goes round the design with backstitch which I thought I could manage quite well already. Alternatively, one can use Holbein stitch, which is a running stitch that is stitched over again with another set of running stitches to fill the gaps, resulting in a smooth line. Sounded easy enough.
Later I learnt that blackwork embroidery originated in the Tudor era and was used extensively to embellish shirts, cuff, necklines – all things that were white and made of evenweave fabric. Shapes were outlined in a thicker black line and filled with dainty regular geometric patterns. Traditionally embroidered with black silk floss on white linen, it certainly looked very elegant.

I popped in to Hobbycraft then, with the aim to buy some crafty birthday presents for Mimi’s little friends, and visited the cross stitch aisle as well. I found the Aida cloth and placed a fat quarter into the basket. When it came to picking up a skein of black floss though I realised that I could not stop there.
Not all is black and white.
There were so many fantastically vivid colours available that somehow ten skeins jumped into the basket, none of which was black. I’m not sure if there was any rational design in my head at this point, but I thought I’d go with the first instinct and try to recreate the heart sampler in colour. No, that’s not right. I wanted to push the concept of playing with colour to the limit by using saturated colours, with multiple combinations, some of which would be dissonant. A little like the Mimi’s rainbow blanket.
These were the colours I picked:
- DMC 893: pink
- DMC 35: aubergine
- DMC 3837: purple
- DMC 3838: blue
- DMC 3844: cyan
- DMC 3812: blue-green
- DMC 703: green
- DMC 726: yellow
- DMC 721: orange
- DMC 3801: red
Yes, I used all of these colours, worked with one strand of floss on 14 count Zweigart Aida.
I selected one colour to be the dominant one, the warm aubergine that I tried to use in every motif, in lieu of black. For the border, I made it more cheerful with a dash of pink. The little diamonds that go round the border reminded me of branches on which buds or flowers sit. Using green for these would have been too conventional, so I worked these in cyan and added pink for blossoms.
Three hearts
Having finished the border, I started work on the bottom heart. This is the most conventional of all. For the filling pattern of this one I used colour transition from aubergine to cyan with pink highlights to match the border. Different colours in the lattice pattern give so much depth to this design, it would be a waste to stitch these black and white! If these were five-petalled flowers, they would be exactly like tiny cherry blossoms!
The middle heart has a distinctly stripey design that screams for a rainbow effect. I made the lower half of the heart resemble the bottom heart of the design, i.e. used the same four main colours: aubergine, purple, blue and cyan. For the top half, I just followed the rainbow. Unfortunately, the yellow didn’t show up on the white as well as I would have liked. I should have either picked a more orangey yellow, or just not used it at all. The end result is not bad, but I made a little modification to the design by adding a dash of orange to the yellow squares.
The filler of the top heart consists of three different motifs: two that resemble flowers that are almost but not quite identical. The third motif is a little like the middle diamonds of the bottom heart. I thought I would use all the rainbow colours here too, but make the flower-like motifs in red and related colours, while keep the remaining one greenish-blue, like leaves peeking out from between flowers. And so the colour-burst heart was born.
The last step was to fill the star motifs sitting between the hearts and add the five stars on top of the hearts. For these I used colours to coordinate the heart motifs.
Learnings and finishing touches
It took me about 5 weeks to complete this little piece, a large chunk done while on holiday. I am not a fast stitcher by any sort of standard, but I expected to finish it quicker. I didn’t really mind though, I discovered how beautifully portable and relaxing handstitching is. I stitched at soft play places while Mimi was running around, in front of the telly while Mimi was watching Hey Duggee for the n-th time, etc. There is always that 5-10 minutes time when we usually reach for our phones and scroll through the news of the day that we don’t actually care about, or numerous social media posts that we can’t relate to anyway – how much nicer is it to take out the hoop and create?
There is only one thing that I found annoying and frustrating about this project: embroidery floss tangles like it set out to wind you up. Now I know that this can be prevented by a tiny amount of beeswax which I didn’t think of when I started. Guess who rushed to buy beeswax after the holiday? Well, talk about shutting the stable door…
There were a couple of occasions where I had to unpick my work. When tutorials describe the Holbein stitch, they warn you about getting lost in more complex designs. They were right. It is quite easy to get lost, though I feel I got much better with practice.
When the actual stitching was over, I mounted the work on a piece of foam board, after overlocking the edges. Overlocking may be a bit of an overkill, but if I worked hard to create this, I certainly don’t want to see it unravel. I didn’t know foam boards before, never had any reason to used any. Mounting my work was certainly a positive experience. It was really easy to pin the aida cloth to the board around the side and then stretch it over the back with regular sewing thread.
I am a bit of a perfectionist, so I also added a layer fabric to cover up the criss-crossing stretching threads. I sewed a little loop on the top so that I could hang the completed item on the wall in the hall. I’m sure it will be a good conversation starter with visitors! I also added my signature label, just in case.
Time to put on the sun-shades!
The end result? I appreciate that it’s not everyone’s cup of tea. It is not calm. It is not elegant. It looks like hormonal overdrive in spring. In the Tudor times the puritans would have burnt it (along with its creator). But. At the risk of getting excommunicated from every embroidery community on the planet, I have to say that I like it. I will be back for more, and I don’t promise to work blackwork in black on white any time soon!
I also asked Mimi what she liked about it and, predictably enough, she picked up a skein of pink from my box. Some things just don’t change…
Edit: wise people on social media revealed that the pattern is available on Etsy from Stitchblackwork. I bought it now, post-mortem so to say, to see if I really did what I was meant to do (apart from the colours, that is). Also because it’s the right thing to do.





















6 comments
This is beautiful, have been looking for a pattern like this for a long time, can you please tell me the finished size, so I can check I have the correct size Aida, have a nice weekend from NEW ZEALAND,
Thank you! It turns out that the pattern is available from Stitchblackwork on Etsy. The finished item for me came to about 5.5×11 inches (this is with a modest border around the actual pattern), depends on Aida count of course. Good luck & please share your work!
I am going to the store this morning and buying everything to do exactly what you did! Gorgeous! Thank you for inspiring me out of the stitching doldrums!
Thank you for your kind words! Don’t forget to make your yellow more orange. And the beeswax… but I don’t need to tell you that probably. 🙂
Good luck!
Hi,
I am Anne from stitchblackwork.
I love what you have done with the design, brought it to life.
I have always been a traditional blackworker, working in black, dark red or dark green but beginning to work with space dyed thread.
Thankyou for posting your work.
Hi Anne, thank you for your kind words, much appreciated. I am looking forward to seeing your work in colour. I am myself working on a tiny little piece in variegated thread… coming soon!
Thank you!
Jed.